Name: Holly Rice
Reading Research Reflection
Marzano Chapter 3
Strategy: Summarizing and Note Taking
Part 1: Summary
Chapter three in the Marzano text Classroom Instruction that Works discusses the art of summarizing and note taking. The first part of the chapter is about the three generalizations of summary research. They include: the deletion of information, substitution of information and the retention of given information, in order to do those three things students must analyze the information at a deep level and students must be aware of explicit structure to summarize the information. The authors then went on to explain the different types of summarizing: rule-based strategy, summary frames and reciprocal teaching. The second part of the chapter included information on note taking. The text offers four essential tips for note taking: verbatim note taking is, perhaps, the least effective way to take notes, notes should be considered a work in progress, notes should be used as a study guide for tests and the more notes that are taken the better. The text describes four types of note taking formats: teacher-prepared, informal, webbing and combination notes.
Part 2: Connection to Another Reading
I think summarizing and note taking go hand and hand with the notion of comparing and classifying from chapter three of the book The Art and Science of Teaching. In this chapter, the authors explore the activity of comparing information to find similarities and differences. I think that note taking and summarizing help students draw conclusions, similarities and differences in the information in which they have read and are classifying. Comparing and contrasting can be a step in the note taking and summarizing process. Students may use the Venn diagram, comparison matrix, and other resources as a way to outline and disseminate the information. Anyway that a student can analyze the information after/during their reading, those processes will help the student to completely understand the information. The more extensive steps of comparing and classifying obviously compare more to note taking and summarizing but all types can be helpful in achieving the main goal of understanding for the students. I also believe that outlining/summarizing and note taking can be an effective type of homework if it is used in the high school level and is checked and discussed after it is assigned. This may be an area where a teacher would want to use teacher guided notes for students to follow when reading a chapter of information for homework.
Part 3: Application to my Teaching
I think teaching note taking is essential in high school and middle school. Before I came to college, I had no idea how to take notes and it is a good thing I am a fast learner. I plan to employ several of the techniques in this chapter to help my students improve and develop note taking and summarizing skills. I really love the idea of reciprocal teaching. My idea for my classroom is lots of discussion, and I believe students could benefit a lot from each other when trying to summarize assigned readings. I also like the example on pg. 35 of the Narrative Frame. This would be a great format to use in my English classes in the future. Sometimes students lose the meaning of a story because it gets so detailed. This would make them think about the specific parts of the story that are ultimately necessary to know. I also liked the idea of the conversation frame. This is another great way for the students to remember back to the story and summarize the important parts and characters. Note taking is an essential part of college, and preparing students for college work is a main role in high school education. I like the idea teacher-prepared notes. This gives students and example to follow with future note taking. It may be a starting point for students; then I may take a few words out and have them fill the words in during their reading or a lecture, and finally, I would let them take the notes themselves. I like the idea of webbing, but I feel like it’s a little too scattered to be really effective during lecture note taking. However, it could be used rather successfully during reading.
I like your ideas about reciprocal teaching and allowing students to learn about taking notes not just assuming they know how to. I think when reading the idea of webbing would greatly help the students learn inside your classroom!
ReplyDeleteI agree that it is important for students to understand how to prepare for higher learning and not just the information they will learn in a higher ED classroom. It doesn't seem productive for student to focus on a specific subject when they have lost out an an important skill like taking notes.
ReplyDelete