Part One: Summary
This chapter in the Marzano text discusses effort and providing recognition. The chapter states two generalizations about reinforcing effort. The first one is that not all students realize the importance of believing in effort. According to the research, some students do not realize that the amount of effort they put into an assignment has an effect on his/her success on the assignment. However, the second generalization states that students can learn to make effort a priority in order to do better on assignments. The chapter also emphasizes the importance of teachers teaching effort to students and showing the connection between effort and achievement. The author suggests showing examples of people who have not given up and gotten to a higher place in life because of it. Students should also give examples of what they have accomplished because they didn’t give up. Another way to teach effort is for a student to keep a log of the correlation between how much they exerted on a project or assignment and the grade they received. The second part of the chapter discusses providing recognition. The authors found three generalizations about recognition. The first was that rewards do not always have a negative impact on intrinsic motivation. The effects can be undermining or enhancing. The only time that rewards have a negative impact on motivation is when that motivation is measured during free time. The second generalization is that rewards are most effective when it is contingent on the attainment of some standard of performance. This means that just rewarding for completion is not always the best idea. It is however good to reward based on a level of the goal attained raises the level of motivation. The third generalization states that abstract symbolic recognition is more effective than tangible rewards. A teacher who is motivated and verbally rewarding to his/her students get better results than a teacher who motivates with tangible rewards (money/prizes etc.). The three types of recognition the book suggests is to personalize the recognition so students realize you really appreciate the effort and work that they (in particular) have contributed. The second is to “pause, prompt, and praise.” This means As the student to stop working, prompt them with specific ideas to help with their project, and then the teacher praises the student if they implement the prompt and do well. After much verbal praise has been given the book does realize that concrete types of recognition are good as well.
Part Two: Connection to Another Reading
This chapter compares to chapter one (pg. 16) in The Art and Science of Teaching text. This part of the chapter addresses the effect of awards on student behavior. The authors report that when children receive oral praise they are more intrinsically motivated. However, the age of the student, and other factors can effect these findings. Overall the trend according to these authors is that when the praise and rewards are used appropriately they can affect student achievement positively.
Part Three: Application to my Teaching
Since I have only been in the classroom for a week, it is hard to have implemented concrete recognition systems. However, I have noticed that I regularly recognize the students’ achievement during class. If they ask me a question, I make sure to let them know they have asked a good question, and then present them with an answer. Also my teacher supervisor and I help establish effort with the kids. They have been working on a paper and we make sure their writing is good and try to encourage them to put their best into their work. I think I’d like to in a classroom establish a concrete recognition system, but it would not be something for everything done in class. It would be a system in which students are recognized for something they have gone above and beyond to accomplish. I will make sure on a daily basis verbal praise/recognition/advice is given to students. I think the littlest of interest/praise given to a student can really make the difference in the amount of effort they put forth.