Sunday, November 14, 2010

Chapter 9

Holly Rice
Reading Research Reflection
Marzano Chapter 9
Strategy: Generating and Testing Hypotheses

Part One: Summary
                Hypotheses can be generated in two manners: inductively and deductively. Deductive predicts a future action or event. Inductive draws new conclusions about information that has already been learned. Inductive reasoning requires students to discover how the principles of the subject matter and then determine a hypothesis. Teachers should also have students explain their hypotheses and conclusions. This process helps students better understand the research and information they have discovered. The chapter also discusses systems analysis. The book suggests that the best way for students to show their understanding of these systems is to form a hypothesis and then predict what would happen if something changed in regards to the system. This formation of hypotheses also stretches to problem solving, historical investigation, invention, experimental inquiry and decision making. These assignments may be difficult, at first, for students. The text suggests to give them some aides to complete the work. The authors suggest giving students templates for their reports, sentences stems, allow them to record their hypotheses on audiotapes, give rubrics and have a Q and A session.               
Part Two: Connection to Another Reading
                Chapter 4 of The Art and Science of Teaching highlights information about hypotheses for students. This text suggests “that activities involving the generation and testing of hypotheses are best organized as comprehensive projects with the teacher serving as a guide,” (pg. 89). The text also discusses experimental inquiry as the quintessential task for generating and testing hypotheses (pg. 91). The book explains this type of inquiry as making a prediction based on observations designing an experiment to test that prediction and then examining the results in light of the original prediction. I actually like the information about hypotheses in the Art and Science book because it is a more scientific book and gives a more detailed account of the information. The action steps really help with the understanding of how to incorporate hypotheses and conclusions into lesson planning and the best ways to explain the information and lessons to your students. The more detailed information is needed for first-time teachers like us. It’s informative and relevant.
Part Three: Application to my Teaching
                I have not seen this incorporated nor have I incorporated it in my lesson planning because it is rather difficult for grammar. However, in a time that I would be teaching reading, I think it may be interesting to have students read up to the climax of a story and then form a hypothesis/conclusion based on the first part of the, the genre of the story and period of time. All of these things contribute to the ending of stories. It could be an interesting research project. It would make reading a story more interesting for the students. Students may also be able to begin research on a certain genre of literature and then form a hypothesis about what they will find in further research. Otherwise, I really can’t think of some other projects for English classes. It is a harder subject to incorporate hypotheses in due to its nature. However, with more thought and experience in an actual classroom, I’m sure I could come up with more ideas, and it’s good to have a little background on the art of doing these types of activities.

Monday, November 8, 2010

Marzano Chapter 10

Holly Rice
Reading Research Reflection
Marzano Chapter 7
Strategy: Cooperative Learning

Part 1: Summary
            This chapter focuses on helping students to retrieve prior information they have already obtained through other outlets of learning. The first topic was cues and questions. These tools should not be centered around interesting things to the teacher; however, they should be centered on what is important for the students to learn and pertinent to the topic at hand. Questions should also be higher level rather than lower level. Higher level thinking questions require students to critically think about the topics and not just regurgitate facts.   Giving a wait time to students is also important. The longer they think about the answer the more in-depth it will be. Asking questions to students before teaching them has an important effect on the learning process. This allows students to have something to think about while they are learning. The chapter also discussed advance organizers; these also allow the activation of prior knowledge. They can be used when information is not easily organized and include several types. These types are narrative, skimming and graphic advanced organizers.
Part 2: Connection of Reading to Another Reading in Class
            Chapter two (pg. 53) in the book the Art and Science of Teaching discusses the use of graphic organizers as a way to help students interact with new knowledge. Much like the Marzano Chapter, this text states that graphic organizers can help recall information students have encountered. Page 32 also discusses the use of advance organizers and cues as part of previewing activities. The chapter refers to these as approaches to student interaction with content. This section of the text talks about how teachers must provide students with direct links between new content and content previously taught. Advance organizers are thought to enhance comprehension and aid in transfer of that information. The chapter suggests that not only do cues, questions and advanced organizers work for students comprehension (like the Marzano chapter suggests), but teachers should preview the information, divide students into small groups, organize the critical-input experience into small chunks or information that students describe, discuss and use to make predictions and ask students questions that require elaborations.
Part 3: Application of Reading to My Own Teaching
            As an English teacher, in my days of clinical work, we have used a lot of graphic organizers. I use a lot of questions and cues to get students thinking. Like today we were working on our dialogue lesson. I asked the students all kinds of questions about how to include dialogue in writing. I referred back to television shows, books and essays that even the students have written. We talked about words to use in taglines and came up with a list of words they have used or have heard or read others use as a way of saying “said.” I feel that this line of questioning activated prior knowledge. Also as a way to organize their thoughts from a brainstorming activity, students use a graphic organizer to outline the information they will include in their papers. I think these tools are very useful for all age groups of students. Background knowledge is such a part of who a person is that it needs to be addressed when teaching new content. 

Marzano Chapter 7

Holly Rice
Reading Research Reflection
Marzano Chapter 7
Strategy: Cooperative Learning

Part 1: Summary
            Chapter 7 of the Marzano Book Classroom Instruction that Works deals with the Instructional Strategy of Cooperative Learning in the classroom. This chapter recommends that groups be determined on ability sparingly. The lower level learners tend to perform worse when grouped with other lower level learners. The book also suggests that group size be rather small, and cooperative learning should be used on specific tasks and not overused. Cooperative learning should be mixed with other teaching strategies so groups do not begin to lose effectiveness. Formal groups are used to thoroughly complete assignments and can be used for several days. Formal groups promote: positive interdependence, group processing, appropriate use of social skills, face-to-face promotive interaction and individual and group accountability. Base groups are for long-term groups and can be used for an entire semester. Informal groups are the shortest of all the groups and last from a few minutes to the end of period.
Part 2: Connection of Reading to Another Reading in Class
            Chapter two in the book the Art and Science of Teaching discusses group/cooperative learning. That chapter is not as detailed as chapter seven, but chapter two discusses how using cooperative learning enhances the processing of new information by interacting with other students. Sometimes students learn better from other students rather than a text book or a teacher. Cooperative learning gives students that chance to interact and learn in a different way.
Part 3: Application of Reading to My Own Teaching
            I think group learning is a great teaching tool. The class that I am working with has not done much group work, but I have seen several places that the teacher could have used cooperative learning. The first was when the class was writing rough drafts of papers. The students should have gotten into groups and made revisions to one another’s papers. This would have not only been beneficial to the write, but also the reader. It would be a different technique in learning to write. The class also worked on a worksheet lesson about Edgar Allen Poe. The answers were difficult to find and some were a little hidden. I think completing the task in groups would have been beneficial. The students would have been able to feed off of one another and explain the information. The students also did a brainstorming activity with a graphic organizer before writing a paper. If students could have worked together on this activity, they could have offered one another information that was not included in their own paper. It’s always good to get an outsiders take on your work because you never know when you may miss something that another person will catch. This is the reason cooperative learning can be so good for the students. However, all aspects must be facilitated properly by the teacher. The teacher has to be active in the cooperative groups. He/she cannot sit back and figure that the groups will run and discipline themselves. Students need help, encouragement and feedback.

Thursday, October 21, 2010

Chapter 4 Marzano

Part One: Summary
                This chapter in the Marzano text discusses effort and providing recognition. The chapter states two generalizations about reinforcing effort. The first one is that not all students realize the importance of believing in effort. According to the research, some students do not realize that the amount of effort they put into an assignment has an effect on his/her success on the assignment. However, the second generalization states that students can learn to make effort a priority in order to do better on assignments. The chapter also emphasizes the importance of teachers teaching effort to students and showing the connection between effort and achievement. The author suggests showing examples of people who have not given up and gotten to a higher place in life because of it. Students should also give examples of what they have accomplished because they didn’t give up. Another way to teach effort is for a student to keep a log of the correlation between how much they exerted on a project or assignment and the grade they received. The second part of the chapter discusses providing recognition. The authors found three generalizations about recognition. The first was that rewards do not always have a negative impact on intrinsic motivation. The effects can be undermining or enhancing. The only time that rewards have a negative impact on motivation is when that motivation is measured during free time. The second generalization is that rewards are most effective when it is contingent on the attainment of some standard of performance. This means that just rewarding for completion is not always the best idea. It is however good to reward based on a level of the goal attained raises the level of motivation. The third generalization states that abstract symbolic recognition is more effective than tangible rewards. A teacher who is motivated and verbally rewarding to his/her students get better results than a teacher who motivates with tangible rewards (money/prizes etc.). The three types of recognition the book suggests is to personalize the recognition so students realize you really appreciate the effort and work that they (in particular) have contributed. The second is to “pause, prompt, and praise.” This means As the student to stop working, prompt them with specific ideas to help with their project, and then the teacher praises the student if they implement the prompt and do well. After much verbal praise has been given the book does realize that concrete types of recognition are good as well.
Part Two: Connection to Another Reading
This chapter compares to chapter one (pg. 16) in The Art and Science of Teaching text. This part of the chapter addresses the effect of awards on student behavior. The authors report that when children receive oral praise they are more intrinsically motivated. However, the age of the student, and other factors can effect these findings. Overall the trend according to these authors is that when the praise and rewards are used appropriately they can affect student achievement positively.
Part Three: Application to my Teaching
                Since I have only been in the classroom for a week, it is hard to have implemented concrete recognition systems. However, I have noticed that I regularly recognize the students’ achievement during class. If they ask me a question, I make sure to let them know they have asked a good question, and then present them with an answer. Also my teacher supervisor and I help establish effort with the kids. They have been working on a paper and we make sure their writing is good and try to encourage them to put their best into their work. I think I’d like to in a classroom establish a concrete recognition system, but it would not be something for everything done in class. It would be a system in which students are recognized for something they have gone above and beyond to accomplish. I will make sure on a daily basis verbal praise/recognition/advice is given to students. I think the littlest of interest/praise given to a student can really make the difference in the amount of effort they put forth.

Monday, October 4, 2010

Marzano Ch. 5

Name: Holly Rice
Reading Research Reflection
Marzano Chapter 5
Strategy: Homework and Practice

Part 1: Summary
                The book covers four generalizations of homework The first stated that the amount of homework assigned to students should be different from elementary to middle to high school. Younger students should be given a lot less homework than older students. The study in this chapter shows that “correct” amounts of homework varies. However, if a student has 30 minutes of homework per night, his/her GPA should increase by 0.50. The second stated that parent involvement in homework should be kept to a minimum. It is apparently unadvisable to have parents help their children with homework. Parents can guide, but should not answer the questions for their child. The third is that the purpose of homework should be identified and articulated. Students should know if the assignment they are doing for homework is for practice at a skill or in order to prepare or elaborate on a certain subject. The fourth is that if homework is assigned it should be commented on. Students should at least get a teacher’s thoughts or grade for doing the homework. The chapter also explains that students and parents should know how the homework in your class will work. A teacher should also design the assignments to show a clear purpose and exactly what is to be gained from the assignment. A teacher  should also vary the approaches to providing the feedback to the students. The chapter also covered practice. According to the chapter, most skills require practice in order to perform at a mastery level, and this practice should be applicable to the things a student is/has learning/ed in class. Practice includes the ability for students to perform the skills accurately and quickly, and a teacher should not try to have students practice a complicated activity all at once. The teacher should break the process up into manageable pieces. If it is too big of an undertaking students will choose not to practice for fear of being too overwhelmed with the information or the process.
Part 2: Connection to another reading
                In chapter three of Marzano’s book The Art and Science of Teaching, the topic of homework is covered (pg. 65).  I liked the reasoning behind this text’s idea for homework and the objective being to extend the learning opportunities outside of the classroom and beyond the school day. This text also reported that homework in the lower levels appears to be less effective than assigning homework in the upper grade levels. However, this book still recommends homework for the younger kids as a way for them to develop study skills. The art and science text also recommends about 10 minutes of homework per night, per grade level. The art and science text also has four useful guidelines for interactive homework. They are much like some of the information in the original Marzano text, but they are very to the point. They include: parents provided with clear guidelines as to their role, parents are not expected to act as experts regarding content and parents ask clarifying questions and questions that help students summarize what they have learned.
Part 3: Application in Teaching
                I would incorporate homework sparingly. I think that parents working with students are very specific assignments is OK, and other assignments should be designated as child only work. As an English teacher, I would prefer for some of the grammar and proofreading exercises to be done by the child alone with limited help from parents, but spelling words and things of that nature should be worked on by students and parents. Homework should also be given a clear explanation of how to do the assignment and exactly why the assignment has been assigned. I plan to do this on the top of the assignments so the children and parents know why I have given the assignment. I also like the idea of assigning homework to younger children to form study skills because skills like these are needed for many students.  Study skills are handy for many years. 

Monday, September 27, 2010

Chapter 6 Marzano

Holly Rice
Reading Research Reflection
Marzano Chapter 6
Strategy: Nonlinguistic Representations

Part 1: Summary
            Chapter 6 of the Marzano Book Classroom Instruction that Works deals with the Instructional Strategy of Nonlinguistic Representations and the importance of giving students instruction other than only linguistic techniques. The book states that giving students the opportunity to create nonlinguistic representations allows them to gain knowledge in a different way and retention of information is greater than with linguistic representations alone. The two guidelines that book gives for using nonlinguistic representations is that they must be varied including: graphic organizers, physical models, mental pictures, drawing pictures or a kinesthetic activity. These representations should also elaborate on knowledge. If the students are using graphic organizers to restate the knowledge they have already gained, it is nothing but a review. However if a graphic organizer reviews prior knowledge and is used to give students a new way to look at that knowledge the information is internalized and the student gains a deeper understanding. Graphic organizers are a type of nonlinguistic representation that actually combines a type of diagram and words to better understand material. Physical Models is a hands-on representation of the material. In a science class, students may learn about volcanoes and make them at the end of the unit. Drawing pictures or pictographs also helps students visualize the information. Essentially they draw something they know in a representation that makes sense to them. Kinesthetic activities are always good in order to keep students interested. This requires movement and creativity to physically express linguistically communicated ideas.
Part 2: Connection of Reading to Another Reading in Class
            Action Step number four in the book the Art and Science of Teaching (pg. 111) addresses an idea like the Kinesthetic Activities of the Marzano text Classroom Instruction that Works. Action Step Four addresses Physical Movement in the classroom. Kinesthetic activities and physical movement go hand in hand. These are great activities to get students involved and also a great way to keep them awake. I liked the idea in the Art and Science text about voting with your feet. It keeps kids moving and allows the teacher the knowledge of who is getting the material and who is not without embarrassment because everyone is answering together. I also like the idea of Give One, Get One. A lot of the first parts of a journalism class is to take notes. This is a great idea to make sure all the students are gathering all the information given.
Part 3: Application of Reading to My Own Teaching
            I think I would use the graphic organizers as a way to construct a story. Starting with the introduction and continuing to the resolution. Students could read the story silently or as a class aloud and express the defining parts of the story in a story board organizer. In a younger class it may be something that a child could draw pictures showing the climax/conflict or something of that nature. For this activity, a graphic organizer like the Episode Pattern (pg 77), or the Process/Cause Effect Organizer (pg 76) could easily be adapted for this type of activity. I also like the idea of Kinesthetic Activities. In this case, I could have students not only read a play in class but act it out as a class project using prompts and costumes in order to better understand the ideas represented in the context of the literature.

Monday, September 20, 2010

Chapter 3

Name: Holly Rice
Reading Research Reflection
Marzano Chapter 3
Strategy: Summarizing and Note Taking

Part 1: Summary
Chapter three in the Marzano text Classroom Instruction that Works discusses the art of summarizing and note taking.  The first part of the chapter is about the three generalizations of summary research. They include: the deletion of information, substitution of information and the retention of given information, in order to do those three things students must analyze the information at a deep level and students must be aware of explicit structure to summarize the information. The authors then went on to explain the different types of summarizing: rule-based strategy, summary frames and reciprocal teaching. The second part of the chapter included information on note taking. The text offers four essential tips for note taking: verbatim note taking is, perhaps, the least effective way to take notes, notes should be considered a work in progress, notes should be used as a study guide for tests and the more notes that are taken the better. The text describes four types of note taking formats: teacher-prepared, informal, webbing and combination notes.
Part 2: Connection to Another Reading
I think summarizing and note taking go hand and hand with the notion of comparing and classifying from chapter three of the book The Art and Science of Teaching. In this chapter, the authors explore the activity of comparing information to find similarities and differences. I think that note taking and summarizing help students draw conclusions, similarities and differences in the information in which they have read and are classifying. Comparing and contrasting can be a step in the note taking and summarizing process. Students may use the Venn diagram, comparison matrix, and other resources as a way to outline and disseminate the information. Anyway that a student can analyze the information after/during their reading, those processes will help the student to completely understand the information. The more extensive steps of comparing and classifying obviously compare more to note taking and summarizing but all types can be helpful in achieving the main goal of understanding for the students. I also believe that outlining/summarizing and note taking can be an effective type of homework if it is used in the high school level and is checked and discussed after it is assigned. This may be an area where a teacher would want to use teacher guided notes for students to follow when reading a chapter of information for homework.
Part 3: Application to my Teaching
I think teaching note taking is essential in high school and middle school. Before I came to college, I had no idea how to take notes and it is a good thing I am a fast learner. I plan to employ several of the techniques in this chapter to help my students improve and develop note taking and summarizing skills. I really love the idea of reciprocal teaching. My idea for my classroom is lots of discussion, and I believe students could benefit a lot from each other when trying to summarize assigned readings. I also like the example on pg. 35 of the Narrative Frame. This would be a great format to use in my English classes in the future.  Sometimes students lose the meaning of a story because it gets so detailed. This would make them think about the specific parts of the story that are ultimately necessary to know. I also liked the idea of the conversation frame.  This is another great way for the students to remember back to the story and summarize the important parts and characters. Note taking is an essential part of college, and preparing students for college work is a main role in high school education. I like the idea teacher-prepared notes. This gives students and example to follow with future note taking. It may be a starting point for students; then I may take a few words out and have them fill the words in during their reading or a lecture, and finally, I would let them take the notes themselves.  I like the idea of webbing, but I feel like it’s a little too scattered to be really effective during lecture note taking. However, it could be used rather successfully during reading.

Monday, September 13, 2010

Chapter 2

Holly Rice


Reading Research Reflection

Marzano Chapter 2

Strategy: Identifying Similarities and Differences



Part 1: Summary

Chapter two of the Marzano book Classroom Instruction that Works deals with the instructional strategy of similarities and differences being taught in the classroom. The text discusses the importance of activities for students to find similarities and differences in order to understand the subject and information more clearly. The information is not only more clear, but the students also are encouraged to continue their thinking beyond what the teacher lectures about or what is in the book. These types of activities emphasize critical thinking and different directional thinking. They take two very seemingly different topics and encourage students to find similarities based on the very abstract. If they understand the deeper meaning, then, the surface meaning stick in their minds longer than just enough for the test. The chapter also gives several ways in which teachers can use activities to encourage the students to draw similarities and differences in the material available to them. The activities explained in this chapter included: comparing, classifying, creating metaphors, creating analogies and the use of graphic organizers to do all of the above. The difference in teacher-directed and student-directed activies were also discussed. It seemed students tended to learn more and understand more in student directed activities. Either way the activities were administered, students grasped concepts more readily when put into the context of similarities and differences.

Part 2: Connection of Reading to Another Reading in Class

I feel like the ideas in Chapter 3 of the Marzano text The Art and Science of Teaching can parallel and add to the idea of instructing students on similarities and differences. The topics of schema development and procedural knowledge are constructed by the use of many things, but one that is a definite builder of these is identifying similarities and differences. When I think of the process of similarities and differences, I think of critical thinking and increasing in-depth knowledge. Schema development and accommodation and assimilation of knowledge. This is the process of gradually building on declarative knowledge (surface information) this kind of knowledge makes bridges between old and new knowledge to develop a deeper understanding of the information. The accommodation changes the exiting knowledge rather than just adding to it. The process of comparing, classifying, creating metaphors and analogies and graphic organizers make the assimilation and accommodation of knowledge feasible. Some of the processes add to the existing knowledge, but some like building metaphors between very different things and comparing them on the most abstract level, make the knowledge they previously have expand and change.

Part 3: Application of Reading to my Own Teaching Interests

Analogies are a big part of an English teacher’s process of teaching. They’re what student must be prepared for on the SAT and are good ways of critical thinking. I liked the idea of the student directed analogies. In this process the students had to do some critical thinking or research in order to connect the blanks in the analogies. These types of exercises would be good to give before a unit test or a research project. It would get the students thinking about all the information that we had learned in the last semester and get them to apply it to their studying. For journalism, Venn diagrams are always a good idea. When collecting ideas for a story, it’s always a good idea to organize ideas. In a Venn diagram, a student could use his/her collected information and place it in the graphic organizer; the right side could be for the body of the story, the middle for what could be included in the lead (first sentence), and left side could be for what is absolutely necessary to include in the lead. This would allow the student to “chunk” the information rather than get overwhelmed with it. It would show that there are similarities in the information, but certain places for everything to go.

Sunday, August 29, 2010

Strategy Reflection Chapter 8

Name: Holly Rice




Reading Research Reflection

Marzano Chapter 8

Strategy: Setting Objectives and Providing Feedback



Part 1: Summary

Chapter eight of the Marzano text addresses the importance of setting objectives for students and providing feedback regarding their work and attainment of said objectives. The chapter gives several examples of objective setting and the pros and cons. In a study conducted regarding goal setting, researchers found that instructional goals limited the information that the students focus on and in turn retain. If a teacher sets a goal to understand one specific thing, students will on remember that one item. (I believe the more students learn the more specific items they retain.) The study also concluded that instructional goals should not be too specific. The more specific the information the less information that students will remember. These types of objectives tell the learner exactly what to focus on and do not give them ample room to learn something that intrigues them in the process. The third conclusion reflects the second. Students should be encouraged to personalize the teacher’s goals; therefore, a student should be encouraged to find something he/she is interested in to gain from the material.

The second part of the chapter dealt with goal setting. The book suggests that goal in which teachers set for their students be specific but flexible. Explanatory feedback is something positive for students. It shows them what they are doing in a way in which they understand. The book suggests that feedback be given in a timely manner. It is also suggested that student-led feedback be incorporated.



Part 2: Connection to another reading in class

In chapter one of Marzano’s book The Art and Science of Teaching, I found several strategies alike to those explained in the book Classroom Instruction That Works. On page 23, action step three encourages teachers to have students set their own learning goals. It affirms that from the first reading which said that enhancing the student involvement in the unit’s subject matter by having them choose something as a goal to learn. Making lessons not only about what the teacher wants/needs the student to learn, but also about what the student wants to learn makes the unit more meaningful personally for the student. The example that Marzano gave about math was really important because often it’s hard for students to draw conclusions about something that they want or may need to learn from a certain math lesson.

Part 3: Application of reading to my own teaching interests

I can relate to this chapter in my ideas of teaching in a journalism high school classroom. I never had a teacher while I was in school who set goals of any sort. After reading this chapter, I realize I want to set goals for my students. I’ve learned some helpful tips for setting goals. If I were to have my students start a lesson on writing the lead (introduction sentence) to a news story. I would sent some general parameters for that lesson. Then I would want them to set some ideas about what they’d like to learn. Maybe one of their ideas would be to learn exactly what a lead does and why it is important. I like the idea of contracts as well. In a journalism class, I think it would be great to set up something like the teacher who was teaching websites. This would allow me to help students individually on specific stories for a publication, and the students could work at their own pace on their own stories.

The feedback portion of the chapter was also very informative. I want to be the teacher who gives positive and constructive feedback. When students write news stories, I want to provide them with feedback that will explain the problems or the positives in order for them to do well on their next assignments. I will definitely be a teacher who gives timely feedback. If a student turns something in and does not receive feedback quickly, the assignment is lost. News stories must get better, and the only way for a student to improve is for he/she to realize and internalize what they have done wrong or right soon after they have completed the assignment. Also I am a big fan of student-peer feedback. I think that a newspaper publication should always be peer reviewed before actual publication. It not only helps the writer, but it also helps the student who is reading the information.